Papa's Pilar Rye-Finished Rum

"The Whiskey Drinker's Rum”

$50.99

Introducing the newest member of our flagship fleet: Rye-Finished Rum. Papa's Pilar Dark rum further finished in White Oak, heavy charred once-used straight Rye Whiskey barrels. At 86 proof, this blend features a long and warm finish with lingering notes of cacao and caramel.

NOSE:
Oak, burnt sugar, dates and baking spices

MOUTHFEEL:
Off-dry, mouth warming, full palate

TASTE:
Oak forward, baking spices, dark chocolate and vanilla bean with subtle hints of coffee

750ml | 43% Alcohol by Volume

From the Press

The Reviews are In

Customer Reviews
4.9 Based on 36 Reviews
5 ★
94% 
34
4 ★
6% 
2
3 ★
0% 
0
2 ★
0% 
0
1 ★
0% 
0
Customer Photos
Write a Review

Thank you for submitting a review!

Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Filter Reviews:
04/12/2025
LG
larry g.
US US

Love Rum

Very nice experience.very smooth and have already bought more

12/17/2024
PS
Paul s.
US US

Perfect cocktail Rum!

We love making rum old fashioneds with this rum. The subtle rye finish balances the sweetness of the rum and simple syrup! Please make a cask strength version...

12/17/2024
SE
Shane E.
US US

Great Rum & Great Service

From the ordering to shipping to receiving the rum everything went very smoothly!

12/17/2024
RB
Robert B.
US US

Papa’s review

Excellent, fantastic packaging material.

11/09/2024
JM
june m.
US US

Pilar

My husband is enjoying them emensly . may order more in the future

11/06/2024
RC
Richard C.
US US

My favorite rum

Very smooth taste. The blend is just right for the rye

10/28/2024
RL
Richard l.
US US

Happy customer

Very timely shipping and excellent packaging. Will be ordering again soon.

06/19/2024
JB
Jill B.
US US

Amazing

I thought the Dark Rum was my favorite until this one. Now, I cannot decide. We have tried other rums but nothing compares to Papa’s Pilar Rum!

03/31/2024
WS
William S.
US US

Excent Finish

Great neat, or mixed in a little hot chocolate!

03/21/2024
KS
Kala S.
US US

Great stuff

So hard to find in liquor stores, I have to order online! This is my son's favorite drink & since I'm staying with him, I always get him some. He loves it & it's the only run he will drink.

02/18/2024
JE
John E.
US US

Perfect

Best rum and superb service

02/04/2024
SG
Suzanna G.
US US

Best tasting ever

Terrific rum the best ever

01/17/2024
EW
Eric w.
US US

Quality of product

An excellent company to deal with! The rye finished rum is exceptional ! As fine a whiskey finished rum I've ever had the pleasure of having! Thanks.

01/09/2024
TA
terry a.
US US

prompt service

great products keep up the fine work and craftmanship

12/15/2023
SE
Shane E.
US US

Rye Finished

The shipping was very fast and received everything in great condition. This is one of the best rums I have ever had with a perfect hint of the rye with the rum.

12/11/2023
MM
Melissa M.
US US

The best!

This is my favorite Rum! Everything arrived well packed and intact. Can’t wait to share it at Christmas!

Explore More

Papa's Pilar
Blonde Rum

$32.99

Papa's Pilar
Dark Rum

$44.99

Papa's Pilar
Sherry-finished Rum

$50.99

Papa's Pilar
Rye-finished Rum

$50.99

Papa's Pilar
rum Trifecta

$128.97