Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
For the Bold & Well-Traveled
$44.99
Papa's Pilar Dark is an ultra-premium sipping rum, bold and well-traveled, much like the man who inspired it - Ernest Hemingway. This 86 proof, award-winning rum has a rich maple, chocolate, ripe fig and candied orange taste profile.
750ml | 43% Alcohol by Volume
The Reviews are In
- Reviews
- Questions
Thank you for submitting a review!
Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
Sampled then bought some dark rum while visiting the distillery in February, decided it was time to order more of this fantastic tasting, old school rum from Key West. Smooth !

Great rum
Papa’s Pilar Rum is a great tasting rum. Ordering is very simple. Shipping was fast and the Pilar’s arrived in good condition. If you like rum or even if you don’t like rum, I think if you will try Pilar’s it might change your mind. I drink my Pilar’s just like I drink my bourbon: over ice.

Drinking a bit of History
This rum is quite enjoyable on the rocks or in traditional rum-based cocktails. Papa's Pilar Dark Rum adds a smoothness and richness--very nice.

Gold Standard
Poor is dark rum is the new gold standard for me!


The Best Rum
Never was a Rum drinker until now. Very smooth. Just drink straight, don't ruin it with a mixer.


Great on it's own, or using in a rum old fashioned
Delightful flavor, very complex and mellow.

Perfect Rum
Fantastic. Placed the order and I arrived within a few days

The Greatest Rum
This is an exceptional rum. We really enjoy it. So far have ordered three bottles. My entire family loves it so much we even got the Pilar’s BBQ Sauce made with the rum. It adds excellent flavor to what ever is on the grill!! Will definitely be ordering more!!!

Just right!
Great online shopping and reliable, on time delivery. And the dark rum is one of a kind. Smooth with a little edginess.

My favorite!
Papa Pilar Rum is outstanding. So smooth! It is my absolute favorite.

The Dark Rum is a winner!
We stopped by the distillery when in Key West last January. We got there late but they stayed open for us. So glad they did. The dark rum has been a real hit with myself and the many people I have shared it with. It’s an amazing tasting rum, that is most definitely my favorite. I will definitely try some of their other rims as well.

The Best Sipping Rum!
We had to order online as it is not sold in stores in North Carolina. Will definitely stock up on our next trip to Florida (heading to the keys in February). Thank you for shipping so quickly!

Dark Rum
Fast shipping, and very good flavor. Will purchase again.

Enjoy
Nice, smooth, and warming with a few rocks to sit back and enjoy the cold weather with. Can't wait to enjoy this in the summer either.