Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
For the Bold & Well-Traveled
$44.99
Papa's Pilar Dark is an ultra-premium sipping rum, bold and well-traveled, much like the man who inspired it - Ernest Hemingway. This 86 proof, award-winning rum has a rich maple, chocolate, ripe fig and candied orange taste profile.
750ml | 43% Alcohol by Volume
The Reviews are In
- Reviews
- Questions
Thank you for submitting a review!
Your input is very much appreciated. Share it with your friends so they can enjoy it too!

The Best Sipping Rum!
We had to order online as it is not sold in stores in North Carolina. Will definitely stock up on our next trip to Florida (heading to the keys in February). Thank you for shipping so quickly!

Dark Rum
Fast shipping, and very good flavor. Will purchase again.

Enjoy
Nice, smooth, and warming with a few rocks to sit back and enjoy the cold weather with. Can't wait to enjoy this in the summer either.

Wonderfully smooth and yummy!
We went to the Distillery in Key West this past Spring….this is most definitely our new favorite Rum!

pouring
still using nice lookin bottle but doesn’t seem to pour in a drip free manner

Papa’ Pilar Dark
One of the smoothest most flavorful rums I have ever had. Been a repeat customer for few years now

Outstanding Product, neat or in monitor! Home run as far as I am concerned! Frederick Indianapolis

Great Rum From Good People
Outstanding experience. Rum is fantastic and the staff & customer service is amazing!

Dark Rum
A very enjoyable experience for me and my wife. Rum on the rocks turned into a mellow evening.

A pleasant surprise
This rum is one of the best sipping liquors I’ve ever tried! I highly enjoyed it over ice. It’s smooth with notes of Carmel and almond, with a slightly sweet flavor. It has a lovely finish! I was impressed. .

Conch Republic Discovery
By far the best thing out of the Conch Republic! Stumbled on it while in Key West two years ago and has been my go to rum ever since. Best neat or on the rocks.

Outstanding blended rum
A very fine blended rum. Perhaps not with the individual character of a single source rum like J Wray or Neptune but actually a more interesting mix of flavors.

A taste of the tropics
Dark rum is spicy! Perfect for a Cuba Libre! Fast shipping. Great packaging and marketing. Will purchase again.

Bye bye bourbon.
Hands down the BEST rum l have ever had! This is what caused me to switch from bourbon to becoming a rum drinker.

Papa Pilar’s Dark Rum
Easy to use and arrived on time! Excellent!

Ecstatic!
So excited to have found this online as I could not find it anywhere in N. Charleston! Family favorite! Smooth & delicious!!!!